We revisit the problem of fair clustering, first introduced by Chierichetti et al., that requires each protected attribute to have approximately equal representation in every cluster; i.e., a balance property. Existing solutions to fair clustering are either not scalable or do not achieve an optimal trade-off between clustering objective and fairness. In this paper, we propose a new notion of fairness, which we call $tau$-fair fairness, that strictly generalizes the balance property and enables a fine-grained efficiency vs. fairness trade-off. Furthermore, we show that simple greedy round-robin based algorithms achieve this trade-off efficiently. Under a more general setting of multi-valued protected attributes, we rigorously analyze the theoretical properties of the our algorithms. Our experimental results suggest that the proposed solution outperforms all the state-of-the-art algorithms and works exceptionally well even for a large number of clusters.